• 0 Posts
  • 82 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 14th, 2023

help-circle














  • “If you put money in a vending machine and got two items instead of one, would you put additional money in for the second item?”

    That is wild.

    The vending company factors this into the prices they charge for the items, the amount they spend on the machine to ensure accuracy, and the amount they pay the people who stock the machines to do it properly.

    If you take it upon yourself to unilaterally re-balance the equation, you’re not being noble, you’re just a fool.


  • The cruel irony of our situation is that we have:

    • An anti-democracy faction, that claims to believe that majority rule and bureaucracy are ineffective, and need to be replaced by a powerful dictator… but has only been able to gain as much ground as it has, because of a multi-decade effort to persuade regular people, build consensus and coalitions, and dive deep into procedure and obscure case law in order to move their agenda forward, one sub-sub-sub-clause at a time
    • A pro-democracy faction, that seems to believe that it’s impossible (or immoral) to try to change people’s minds, and that if an action won’t result in radical, comprehensive, overnight revolution all at once then it’s basically not worth doing



  • Yeah, we need to be careful about distinguishing policy objectives from policy language.

    “Hold megacorps responsible for harmful algorithms” is a good policy objective.

    How we hold them responsible is an open question. Legal recourse is just one option. And it’s an option that risks collateral damage.

    But why are they able to profit from harmful products in the first place? Lack of meaningful competition.

    It really all comes back to the enshittification thesis. Unless we force these firms to open themselves up to competition, they have no reason to stop abusing their customers.

    “We’ll get sued” gives them a reason. “They’ll switch to a competitor’s service” also gives them a reason, and one they’re more likely to respect — if they see it as a real possibility.